Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Indy 500: Coverage of the 'Greatest Spectacle In Racing'

Evan Longoria Wins Gold Glove; Carl Crawford & B.J. Upton Robbed Once More

What I'm about to say has absolutely no bearing on Evan Longoria's accomplishment. He is one of the few winners of the mark of "defensive excellence" that actually deserves to be crowned. Here's what the Rays presser had on Longo:

"It's the one award that I've wanted to win since I started pro ball," Longoria said.  "I take a lot of pride in my defense, so this award is very special to me.  It's humbling to have your name associated with some of the great players who have won a Gold Glove, especially the third basemen.  I would like to thank the managers and coaches who voted for me and I'd also like to thank Carlos Peña.  We all know how good he is.  He probably saved me at least five errors this year so without him the award might not have been possible."

Since 1990, only seven players have won a Gold Glove at a younger age than Longoria:

Player, Team                  Year(s)                  Age(s)

Ken Griffey, Jr., SEA      1990-91-92-93      20-21-22-23

Ivan Rodriguez, TEX     1992-93-94-95      20-21-22-23

Andruw Jones, ATL       1998-99-2000       21-22-23

Roberto Alomar, TOR   1991                      23

Scott Rolen, PHI            1998                      23

Eric Chavez, OAK          2001                      23

Jeff Francoeur, ATL       2007                      23

Evan Longoria, TB               2009        23

That being said, Carl Crawford and B.J. Upton deserved it nearly as much and neither wins one yet again. The managers and coaches vote on these things and it's just insane to think they have a good grasp on who is and who is not a good defender based on - at most - seeing 18 games against these players. It's purely reputation based and even then they get it wrong.

Star-divide

Instead of Crawford and Upton, Adam Jones and Torii Hunter win the two non-Ichiro awards. I won't fake disgust because these, like the other awards, are absolutely meaningless when it comes to honest player valuation, but someone please make sense of this:

Flawed mainstream:

Errors

Upton 4

Crawford 4

Jones 5

Hunter 1

Fielding Percentage

Upton .990

Crawford .988

Jones .986

Hunter .997

Assists

Upton 6

Crawford 6

Jones 9

Hunter 2

Less flawed and esoteric:

UZR

Upton 11

Crawford 17.6

Jones -4.7

Hunter -1.4

+/-

Upton -1

Crawford 18

Jones -11

Hunter 4

Fans Scouting Report positional ranks

Upton 5th

Crawford 2nd

Jones 25th

Hunter 13th

Or:

Player E F% A UZR Dewan Fans Average
Upton 2 2 2 2 3 2 2.2
Crawford 2 3 2 1 1 1 1.7
Jones 4 4 1 4 4 4 3.5
Hunter 1 1 4 3 2 3 2.3

 

Hooray for the human element.

Comment 31 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

As Jason Bays agent says

The only things that matter in outfield defense are errors and assists!

www.draysbay.com

by Tommy Rancel on Nov 10, 2009 3:37 PM EST via mobile reply actions  

Longoria is the youngest player to win an AL gold glove since...

Eric Chavez. Joins Brooks Robinson, Scott Rolen and Chavez as the youngest 3B to win one.

www.draysbay.com

by Tommy Rancel on Nov 10, 2009 3:39 PM EST via mobile reply actions  

Rob Neyer is all over it with a skathing criticism

It doesn’t matter that he didn’t mention CC or Upton, he just nails it anyway.

http://espn.go.com/blog/SweetSpot/post/_/id/1314/more-gold-gloves-more-head-scratching

I can't wait until we trade him for a reliever.

by kericr on Nov 10, 2009 4:27 PM EST reply actions  

hahaha...

he says youk should have won it at first. He played a whole 78 games there this year.

by tbmd on Nov 10, 2009 5:07 PM EST up reply actions  

Neyer has some misses too though.

Like this: “Polanco is a pretty good second baseman, but nowhere near as good as Dustin Pedroia”

……………….UZR……UZR/150
Polanco…… 11.4……..11.0
Pedroia……..9.8………10.6

I didn’t look at the other metrics, but I would guess they’re at least close.

by nolesblogger on Nov 10, 2009 5:23 PM EST up reply actions  

Yeah and UZR should really be looked at in 3 year sample sizes

and given a 3 year sample, they’re just about exactly the same defensively.

Tools Whore

by Tyler on Nov 10, 2009 5:52 PM EST up reply actions  

Crawford and Upton robbed all right

I hate that this is the first time an Oriole wins a GG in a bajillion years and I can’t even feel good about it.

Some Day, Matt Wieters Will Make The Cooperstown Crowd Laugh By Talking About The Time He Batted Behind Melvin Mora And Luke Scott. -Keith Law via Matt Wieters Facts

by Stacey on Nov 10, 2009 4:31 PM EST reply actions  

It's better that CC and BJ didn't win

Now Rays can use that against them in negotiations. BJ would get more in arb as a gold glove CF. When talking to CC’s agent about an extension, Friedman can drop the “how many gold gloves does he have?” on him.

www.draysbay.com

by Tommy Rancel on Nov 10, 2009 4:42 PM EST via mobile reply actions  

I feel a little sick.

I am so tired of no-legs Derek Jeter winning that stupid award.

by BWoodrum on Nov 10, 2009 5:20 PM EST reply actions  

He's only won it three times before,

which is three more times than he deserves, but still it’s not like a Hunter or Ichiro-esque monopoly.

by ChristopherA on Nov 10, 2009 5:54 PM EST up reply actions  

Games played don't matter though

It’s how good you were during them, just like Raffy had some crazy 28 games which he must’ve made all 27 outs in the field.

by Transplanted on Nov 10, 2009 6:06 PM EST up reply actions  

Congrats Longo

When’s the last time a LF won the award? If Craw played his more natural position it would be a moot point.

I'm not really a NUMBERS guy!!

by Andy Hellicksonstine on Nov 10, 2009 6:13 PM EST reply actions  

As much as I appreciate the focus on center fielders being better defenders.

A bad center fielder is not more deserving than a great corner outfielder.

by R.J. Anderson on Nov 10, 2009 6:17 PM EST up reply actions  

This is true.

And by the same token, aren’t shortstops usually better defenders than second basemen, and aren’t the lesser shortstops often moved there much as fading center fielders go to left field? It seems to me that the awards ought to be for discrete positions all around, not just in the infield and battery.

I think it is particularly egregious in right field where some center fielders do not have the arm to play as effectively as a top notch right fielder does. But I see no reason for the award not to be divided among the 3 outfield positions. As I understand it, Gutierrez should be the center field GG with Crawford getting the award for LF.

by bobr on Nov 11, 2009 11:09 PM EST up reply actions  

Look man, don't blindside three dog like that

Playing center involves thinking and thinking is not cc’s game. Yea, Buddy.

www.draysbay.com

by Tommy Rancel on Nov 10, 2009 6:20 PM EST via mobile up reply actions  

I think it might've been Rickey

If it was that was back in 1981, so it’s been a while since a true LF won it, evidence they need to fix the OF awards.

by Transplanted on Nov 10, 2009 6:27 PM EST up reply actions  

Crawford being overlooked is surprising.

BJ Upton has too bad a reputation to be able to contend for an award at this time. His own media calls him lazy and he has a terrible offensive year (which unfortunately factors in).

Almost polar opposite, Crawford seemed to have everything going for him. He made a great defensive play during the All-Star game and had a pretty good year all around. Not sure what he has to do to snag one.

by tallyray on Nov 10, 2009 7:25 PM EST reply actions  

What do you really expect?

Palmeiro was awarded a GG in ’99 and he played 135 games as a DH.

Absolutely zero validity to this award so no reason to get all up in arms about.

by RaysnNoles on Nov 11, 2009 12:42 PM EST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Founded in 2005, DRaysBay is home to, "Progressive statistical analysis and reasoned argument."

Please read our Community Guidelines.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Spts-shelton_small
Which Red Sox Fan Are You?
Spts-shelton_small
The Opportunity of the Century
Ryu_small
This one goes out to all the chicken littles
Small
MLB needs to help bring All-Star game to Bay Area
Small
Who's That in My Old Seats?

Recent FanPosts

Images_small
Turning F**cking Point: Post-Game Reactions
Untitled4_small
The Rays Should 'Retaliate' By Winning
Whelk_small
Rays 7, Sox 4; Immediate Reactions
Images_small
Post-Game (Over)Reactions here
Small
Proposal: Rays play a series in Durham each year
Ag_-_hector_gomez_-_63_small
Visiting Tampa Bay from Colorado
Images_small
Immediate Reactions: Rays Win, But Likely Lose Another Guy

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

FanShots

Quick hits of video, photos, quotes, chats, links and lists that you find around the web.

Recent FanShots

Catch For the Ages
Brandon Guyer out for season
Other Side of the Coin: Rodney's Fortune on Called Strikes
Does anyone have any information on Josh Sale? He doubled in a run in his...
Orlando Hudson released
Rays sign Garko to minor league...
Baseball Card Fans...check out my Ebay Auctions
Cameron Seitzer Growing Up Baseball
Longo injury apparently is apparently not good
Hak-Ju Lee, SS, Rays (Double-A Montgomery) Lee had a breakout year in...

+ New FanShot All FanShots >

Friends of the Site

DRB Suggestion Box

Drb4_medium

Yahoo_full_count

Managers

Slowsky__1__small Steve Slowinski

Images_small Jason Collette

Brad_small BWoodrum

Price_small Erik Hahmann

Analysts

Small td32

Rutg_uakjmedjwh9ndzd4lkll_small Imperialism32

100_1952_small MrNegative1

Steak-with-crown_small CBJones

Whelk_small Whelk

Scaled_php_small mr. maniac

Tampa_theatre_small jcmitchell

Me_small John Gregg

Small SGrauer