Left Side Is The Best Side: Is There A Better Duo Than Evan Longoria & Jason Bartlett?
It's a little early to look at All-Star ballots and things of that nature, but has there been a better left side of the infield this season than Evan Longoria and Jason Bartlett? Sure, there are talented SS/3B tandems throughout the league like Alex Rodriguez and Derek Jeter or David Wright and Jose Reyes, but offensively and defensively nobody is playing as well as the Rays left side.
I guess you could argue that Hanley Ramirez and replacement level third basemen X would make a fine pair, but Longoria basically cancels out Ramirez's advantage over your normal every day shortstop. Add that to the fact that Jason Barlett has looked like a team MVP, if that team didn't already have guys like Longoria, Carl Crawford or Carlos Pena, and you have a winner. In fact with a .401 wOBA Bartlett has been one of, if not the best, offensive short stop north of Miami where Ramirez makes his living.
Offensively, I don't have to tell you how good Longoria is. And just yesterday, I did a little piece on how he is now the games premier defensive third basemen. Longo is the real deal, and while MVB"s offensive start maybe too good to be true for much longer, his defense is starting to resemble the player we thought we were getting from the Minnesota Twins.
Over the past three seasons including last year's 2.1 UZR, Bartlett has averaged a 7.1 UZR. Figuring (or hoping) last year was the outlier, most suspected a healthy Bartlett would climb back closer to the 8-10 range this season. So far that looks to be the case. Barlett is third overall in SS UZR with a 3.0 ranking and is tied for second in range runs. It looks like whatever knee problem that hampered him last year is over and done with. One thing I did notice is he has been average or below average at turning the double play, or at least he is according to Fangraphs' double play runs.
If both players keep up this level of play it might not matter who the fans vote in as the All-Star starters at each position. Remember, Joe Maddon is the manager of the AL All-Star team. If we're talking about the same two players into next month, then Maddon will be more than justified in showing a little homerism and taking the left side of his infield, and maybe part of the right side in Carlos Pena, with him to St. Louis.
Note: Keep in mind we are dealing with a small sample size and metrics like UZR are great at telling us what has happened so far, but hold little weight as a predicitive value.
23 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
What happens next year?
Do you think they Rays bring Bartlett back next year? I would think he would be looking for a long term contract… with the SS the Rays have in the minors, do you think they would be willing to let him go and bring a younger kid in?
In my opinion, letting Bartlett go would be a big mistake
Doesn't matter if Bartlett wants a long-term deal.
He’s here for at least the next two seasons if the Rays want him.
by R.J. Anderson on May 12, 2009 3:08 PM EDT up reply actions
Bat and Knee
If his bat comes back down to Earth (expected) and his knee remains healthy (hopefully), he is an above average player at worst as his defense is solid and for a #8 or #9 bat provides us with a little pop and some good directional hitting.
He may have hit his ceiling, but barring injury, I can’t see him falling too far.
This is the best case scenario
The most important part of his game is defense. If that remains and it looks like it will if healthy, then the good offense is just a bonus.
www.draysbay.com
by Tommy Rancel on May 12, 2009 3:17 PM EDT up reply actions
wRAA (wOBA translated to runs, versus league average), UZR, positional, and replacement/playing time.
Cameron wrote a long series about it, here, http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/index.php/glossary/, at the bottom.
by R.J. Anderson on May 12, 2009 3:22 PM EDT up reply actions
Thanks
Will do my homework tonight so I can speak 2% of the language that is spoken here.
Good to get some background info though.
Go ahead and take a bow
you write some good stuff there too
Give Barty a three year deal
put Brignac at 2B, and leave Aki go
I don't think re-signing Bartlett makes a lot of sense.
He’s not out of here until after 2011. Beckham should be near ready by then.
by R.J. Anderson on May 12, 2009 3:57 PM EDT up reply actions
Bartlett will be 32 after 2011. Perfect time to replace
www.draysbay.com
by Tommy Rancel on May 12, 2009 4:02 PM EDT up reply actions
Dunno... Longo and Wright's bats are pretty comparable, and Longo owns Wright in defense.
Not that Wright’s a terrible defender, but his reputation proceeds him. Reyes is obviously more likely to end the year with better numbers than Bartlett, but at this very moment? Barty owns, yo.

by 





















