Book Review: "Positional Hitting" by Jaime Cevallos
As we continue our mid-season refresher, I decided to take a step back from Statistics and take a look at something that leans more toward the scouting crowd.
More than a year ago, I attempted to crack what is now known as The Zobrist Code. As the story goes, Ben Zobrist went from a below-average major league hitter to an American League All-Star within the span of a calendar year. Many were amazed by the transformation that took Zobrist from back-up infielder to Zorilla, yet few (none) bothered to investigate why. After weeks of searching, I came across one man who stepped forward from the shadows to shed some light; that man is Jaime Cevallos.
Over the last year, we've highlighted Cevallos' work with Zobrist, including speaking to Zobrist himself. Just this off-season, another member of the Tampa Bay Rays organization, Justin Ruggiano, jumped aboard with "the swing mechanic's" unique approach to training.
Cevallos has many skeptics - including some on this site - however, his belief in his system remain strong as ever.
Along the way, there have been calls for more information on Cevallos' revolutionary teaching philosophy. Well, your calls have been answered with Jaime Cevallos' new book: Positional Hitting: The modern approach to analyzing and training your baseball swing.
After the jump, you'll find a preview/review of the book. As I received the book, Jaime's one request was for un-biased and honest review. Here goes...
First off, Positional Hitting is not an autobiography loaded with ego-driven success stories. It is only in the first few pages that Cevallos gives background on why he does what he does:
"I had made myself into a good hitter and I did it by changing a few positions through my swing. I had cracked open a door to a world that nobody else seemed to know exist - the door to Positional Hitting." - Jaime Cevallos
The rest of the book reads like a how-to instruction manual for improving your swing and becoming a better overall hitter. For those who have been hoping for an inside look at Cevallos' method, you'll get a full fix. Before letting you into his positional hitting world, the Swing Mechanic lets us in on the eleven myths that have held hitters back. If you watch just one baseball broadcast in your life, you will hear nearly all eleven at some point or another. I won't list all eleven, but I can't resist one of them, considering we hear it often in Tampa Bay.
On a nightly basis, Kevin Kennedy will tall about "staying inside the ball." Cevallos explains that this myth is a "close relative" of drive the ball the other way, another favorite of Kennedy. However, Jaime explains that a "stay inside the ball" swing shortens the Area of Impact (AOI), and less force is transferred from the bat to the ball. It also forces a hitter to make a decision to swing the bat too early - a big no-no in Cevallos' eyes.
One of Cevallos' major league students describes the positional hitting training as "swing yoga." This is possibly the perfect explanation for what Cevallos does. Unlike traditional exercises, yoga takes an unconventional approach to achieve a similar goal. Positional hitting, like traditional hitting techniques, is designed to make you better at hitting a baseball; however, a moving baseball is never used. Instead, Cevallos uses videos to measure swing angles, and he studies things like AOI as well as the key positions of the swing.
The meat of the book is spent looking at each position in detail. There are seven positions in total: the fall, cushion, slot, impact, delivery, finish, and guard. Positions are a huge part of Cevallos' training. As he says, "the real secret to hitting is in continuously improving the positions that you achieve through the swing as seen on video." He goes on to add, "For those who attain the key positions, hitting is effortless and fun. For those who don't, hitting will always be a struggle."
Again, I could go on in great length about all seven. Instead, I'll talk briefly about my favorite position: the slot. This position occurs after the stride in the forward swing, just after you decide to swing*.
*A misconception about the training is it is all about power. However, a good part of the technique is spent on pitch recognition and selection.
A major part of the slot position is bat lag - "the point where your back elbow falls close to your side, and the bat momentarily fires toward the pitcher behind you." Cevallos explains it is important to achieve maximum bat lag early in the slot position to increase bat speed. Achieve max bat lag too late, and you'll be rolling on pitches causing weak grounders and shallow flyballs. We have seen our fair share of both from the Rays' offense this season.
This is just an extremely small sample of things you can learn in the book. Cevallos also incorporates illustrations throughout the book, giving you visuals to follow along with. In addition to telling you about the positions and what they mean, there are also drills for each to help you try the training for yourself.
In conclusion, I believe Cevallos nails what he intended to accomplish with Positional Hitting: giving outsiders and insiders, believers and non-believers, an all-access pass to his modern approach on swing analysis and training. Do I believe this system will turn every average hitter into a major league star? No. Is it the sole reason for Zobrist's transformation? Not likely. But do I think the swing mechanic's methods can turn a good hitter into a better hitter? Yes - with the proper balance of teaching and, of course, talent.
For players of the game and fans who are open to thinking outside of the box - going beyond traditional approaches that have been in place for more than a century - Positional Hitting should definitely be a part of your process. Results, however, may vary.
Thank you to Jaime for providing me with a copy of his book. If you are interested in learning more about positional hitting, you can order your copy here.
12 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Hmmm...
May have to add this to the offseason reading. Have you read Teddy Ballgame’s book on the science of hitting? How would it compare if you had?
I have not although Steve Slow and I have talked about both in passing emails
This book in particular is really a how-to-improve your swing manual, as it gives you specific drills to do and tells what angles to look for as you study the video.
We are so deeply rooted in stats since they’re easy to look at and readily available, but stuff like this fascinates me. I wish I could spend a few games with a scout. The book is an easy read (100 pages or so), but I have referenced it a few times as I’ve watched games and went back to look for certain things on DVR.
www.draysbay.com, www.bloombergsports.mlblogs.com, Twitter @trancel
by Tommy Rancel on Jul 14, 2010 10:17 AM EDT via mobile up reply actions
No doubt.
It’s actually perfect for stuff like that. It’s one thing to look for certain things during a MLB game for analysis, but actually using it to teach would be awesome.
www.draysbay.com, www.bloombergsports.mlblogs.com, Twitter @trancel
by Tommy Rancel on Jul 14, 2010 10:30 AM EDT via mobile up reply actions
My thoughts exactly.
The Williams book is pretty theortecial, so it’s kinda hard to hammer in to the heads of 14 YOs (he kids’ ages I’ve been coaching). It’d be nice to use the postures/poses/whatever to help instruct them. The challenge will then be getting them to actually do it.
The Williams book is great, from the brief bit I've read in the past
I need to sit down and read the whole thing finally. Feel like at the very least, it’d make me a more informed viewer.
I love Casey Fossum. Now try and take me seriously.
by Steve Slowinski on Jul 14, 2010 10:36 AM EDT up reply actions
The use of video
is the key to success.That post about the travel of Mo’s cutter,is an example.People always say numbers don’t lie,and I agree,as long as there is no hidden agenda behind them.The real truth is video does not lie as long as all angles are covered.That crap about staying inside the ball,and drive the ball the other way,always drives me crazy.Great post Tommy
Staying inside the ball
allows you to wait longer and let the ball get deeper, so your legs can have more impact… allows you to hit the outside pitch hard the other way, the pitch down the middle on the screws and the inside pitch in play without curving a mile foul… that’s been my experience with working with hitters. But I do understand the misconceptions about it. Kind of explains Zobrist’s decline in power this year and confirms my suspicions about his swing this year. He seems to be a little early, particularly on the outside… He’s still a good hitter though and has become more patient the last month.
Forget Williams, buy “The Mike Schmidt Study”, the full version. It compares/contrasts Williams with Charlie Lau – the two prevalent theories from the 70’s to 90’s. It then introduces the “Hybrid” method of the two which is the most current style in use excepting the true power guys (rotational/Williams) and fast lefties (linear/Lau).
I’ll definitely buy the book to see what’s new and what’s relabled. I bet he does have some great drills if he’s incorporating a yoga style of teaching.
Ben started working
on his swing with Jaime ,before the 2008 season.He credits his power surge to Jaime’s instruction.Your critic of Ben’s decline in power this season is not applicable to Jaime’s instuction.
I never said it was
Jaime’s instruction. Hitter’s fall out of their groove in minute ways. A part of what I read kind of explained what I see with Ben’s swing not being quite where it was last season, That’s on Ben, not on Jaime. I ordered the book, I actually ordered the bat also. When the book gets here, I’ll read and digest it, then I’ll get a couple of kids over and work with them and get some feedback. Then I’ll draw my own conclusions.
Things written on the internet
sometimes need further explanation.I was trying to clarify the time line of Ben’s contact with Jaime.If not for you, for others that may read the post. I didn’t want readers getting the impression that Ben had power and then lost it because he was not staying inside the ball.
In defense of Kennedy (which I cringe to do)
When he is talking about hitting the other way, and how it is a sign the batter is making the right adjustments, I believe he is referring to taking the outside pitch and driving it the other way. Players often slump because they try to pull every ball. Trying to pull an outside pitch will likely result in failure. Either a strike out or a weak grounder to the pull side is the usual result. Driving the ball to the opposite field is a sign the player is patient at the plate, and will make better contact on outside pitches. If Kennedy was suggesting that hitting the ball to the opposite field is good regardless of pitch location, I missed that.
Zobrist looks to me like he has changed his weight distribution to his front leg in his swing. This sometimes can help keep the bat in the plane of the ball longer, leading to more line drives and ground balls, but far less power. It is commonly seen in high average, low power, lead off type hitters.

by 







![Zobrist wallpaper I made :]
Actual Link: http://i1207.photobucket.com/albums/bb472/lewiedesigns/Wallpapers/Zobristwallpaper.jpg](http://cdn1.sbnation.com/fan_shot_images/237766/Zobristwallpaper_small.jpg)


















