Previous answers: Tuesday (Jake McGee)
Wednesday: There are three Rays pitchers with similar repertoires, and y'all got the right three.
For comparison, Josh Lueke looks like this:
Joel Peralta looks like this:
But the correct answer -- identified by Andy Hellicksonstine, BossmanJunior333, Dbullsfan, AndrewTorrez, TBRaysfan009, and BeantownRaysFan -- was my reliever-crush, Brandon Gomes:
Everybody who was right today answered correctly yesterday as well, so they're the leaders.
Here's today's puzzle:
Who is the mystery Ray?