clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

ALDS Game 4 Preview: Tommy Hunter vs. Every Left Handed Batter on the Roster

Ben Zobrist is wanted for questioning in relation to a police inquiry surrounding recently murdered balls and robbed line drives.  (Photo by Ronald Martinez/Getty Images)
Ben Zobrist is wanted for questioning in relation to a police inquiry surrounding recently murdered balls and robbed line drives. (Photo by Ronald Martinez/Getty Images)
Getty Images

After yesterday's improbable comeback -- improbable given our recent performance -- I feel as though any additional Rays baseball is just bonus. I -- like many others -- had begun the lamenting process, quietly rosterbating over some tear-stained spreadsheets.

I know the post-season is a cruel mistress, always calling me at my house when my wife is around. And so I shouldn't have been too surprised when she began tossing my possessions across the room, screaming, "I swear to God, I'll sweep your team if I want!"

"You wouldn't dare! We just spent all that time winning the toughest division in baseball! Would you really through throw all that away just because you are a crusty botch of nature*?" 

*from: Troilus and Cressida, by Wm. Shakespeare

Indeed she would. The Playoffs really doesn't care for the talents involved on either side -- it recklessly tosses about wanton wins to the deserving and undeserving alike. One of the positive things to come out of yesterday's game: I actually happened to be recording at the precise moment I decided to kill home-plate umpire Jerry Meals.

So now we face Game 4 of the ALDS, or Bonus Game 1 of the Fickle Playoffs System. Of all the pitching match-ups thus far, this one favors us most.

Tommy Hunter vs. Wade Davis
This is what you will hear TBS's mind-numbingly bad announcers say tomorrow: Tommy Hunter has had a great season with the Rangers, going 13-4 with a 3.73 ERA. He's a crafter pitcher who mixes cutter and curves to keep hitters off-balance, but doesn't blow anyone away with his 90 mph fastball. He's one of the young stars of the game who know how to win games and Cliff Lee, Cliff Lee, Cliff Lee, ahmen.

Here's the truth: Tommy Hunter has enjoyed some rare luck. He sports an 80% LOB% and a 4.70 xFIP. On top of that, his career xFIP against lefties sits at 5.07 (HAHAHAHA!!! Guess which side of the plate most of our best hitters hit from?). This makes sense for a guy who relies on a cutter and a non-12-6 curve because both tail in towards lefties and thus look FAT.

Also, Hunter's 2010 BABIP vs. righties is nearly .040 lower (.223) than his career average (.261). In other words, if the Rays strike out more than 4 times and score less than 3 runs on Tommy Boy, then Destiny has simply frowned on us.

From the opposite dugout, the Rays send the venerably bearded Wade Davis. Davis does not have an especially shiny xFIP (4.81) or a good-luck-free LOB% (78.1%), but as StaplesManiac pointed out the other day (whilst in the middle of completely obliterating my post about Wade Davis), the cumulative numbers undersell Davis:

As the second half of the season progressed, his LOB% moved downward:



...his BABIP went up:



...yet his FIP went down!



There are two possible explanations here: (1) Davis got lucky with HR/FB (or his luck simply balanced out -- he finished near league average) or (2) Davis got better and sharper.

Either way, Davis was a 4.00 FIP pitcher after the All-Star Break -- and one with completely neutral platoon splits (4.58 career xFIP verse both hands).

Ben Zobrist and Carlos Pena, Save Us!
On the other side of the coin -- the offense -- we have had two shining glimmers of hope this post season: Ben Zobrist and Carlos Pena. In the first two games, Zobrist couldn't help but murder the ball -- unfortunately it kept landing in open gloves. In Game 3, Pena starting showing flashes of 2007, slapping line drives and crushing towering fly balls.

Dan Johnson -- despite receiving prison treatment from Jerry Meals -- also went 2 for 3 with a walk and a double; and Carl Crawford also hit a Texas-style homer out to right. BUT! If we want to win Game 1 of the Bonus Round, a hot Carlos Pena makes the task easy!

Pena's wRC+ by month shows us when he's hot, he's Mark Walhberg-without-a-shirt hot:

Mar/Apr  137
May       37
Jun      153
Jul      149
Aug      130
Sept/Oct  45

If Zobrist can hit the ball like it's 2009 -- or just get on base like it's 2010 -- and if Pena gets hot, then we can start warming up Dan Wheeler for the 8th and 9th innings.