Because we’re a first-past-the-post voting system, Jaime Schultz won one of the more interesting polls I can recall in doing these lists. He has the fewest votes of a winner so far, and they came in the poll with the most votes total.
I also believe this is the first time someone who didn’t finish in second in the previous poll won a vote.
Just one tester for this poll.
2017 Community Prospect List
|SS Willy Adames||22||35||62.9%|
|RHP Brent Honeywell||36||37||97.3%|
|RHP Jose De Leon|
|1B/OF Jake Bauers||22||38||57.9%|
|1B Casey Gillaspie||24||34||70.6%|
|RHP Chih-Wei Hu||16||38||42.1%|
|3B Joshua Lowe*||20||32||62.5%|
|RHP Jacob Faria||24||41||58.5%|
|OF Jesus Sanchez||19||37||51.4%|
|IF Daniel Robertson||15||34||44.1%|
|IF Adrian Rondon||16||40||40.0%|
|RHP Jaime Schultz||13||43||30.2%|
|SS Lucius Fox||11||32||34.4%|
|3B Kevin Padlo||10||37||27.0%|
|OF Garrett Whitley||13||36||36.1%|
|RHP Hunter Wood||12||37||32.4%|
|OF Justin Williams||17||39||43.6%|
|RHP Taylor Guerrieri||15||31||48.4%|
|LHP Ryan Yarbrough||26||38||68.4%|
|RHP Ryne Stanek||14||35||40.0%|
|C David Rodriguez||14||32||43.8%|
|RHP Austin Franklin||10||32||31.3%|
|LHP Genesis Cabrera||9||30||30.0%|
|C Nick Ciuffo||12||34||35.3%|
|OF Joe McCarthy*||25||34||73.5%|
|C Brett Sullivan||10||37||27.0%|
|IF Carlos Vargas||11||36||30.6%|
|OF Jake Fraley||17||37||45.9%|
|RHP Kevin Gadea||16||36||44.4%|
|C Chris Betts||13||31||41.9%|
OF Eleardo Cabrera (L/R, 5'11 195, 21 in 2017)
2016 statistics with rookie-level Princeton: 270 PA, .311/.375/.466, 7 HR, 21 XBH, 8-for-12 SB, 6.3 BB%, 27.0 K%
Cabrera burst onto the domestic-league scene in 2016 with a strong season for Princeton. He led the Appalachian League in hits, tied for the league lead in homers and was among the team leaders in many offensive categories. However, it's his strong arm and outfield defense that are his calling cards. He makes good contact and has some speed, but he has to work on his approach.
LHP Genesis Cabrera (6'1 170, 20 in 2017)
2016 statistics with Class-A Bowling Green: 116 IP, 3.88 ERA, 1.36 WHIP, 9.8 BB%, 19.6 K%
As one of the 10 youngest pitchers in the Midwest League, and second youngest to throw 100-plus innings, Cabrera enjoyed a solid 2016 season with the Hot Rods. According to 2080 Baseball, his fastball touches the mid-90s with a promising breaking ball and changeup. He struggled down the stretch, which could certainly be a result of fatigue, as he set a career high in innings by 86 2/3 frames. He should cut down on his walks a bit, but he wasn't hopelessly wild.
OF Johnny Field (R/R, 5'10 180, 25 in 2017)
2016 statistics with Double-A Montgomery and Triple-A Durham: 491 PA, .273/.322/.453, 51 XBH, 12 HR, 16-for-24 SB, 6.1 BB%, 21.6 K%
After losing Tyler Goeddel and Joey Rickard in last year's Rule 5 draft, the Rays risked losing another right-handed-hitting outfielder this time around, but they were able to retain Field. He has already had a lot of success in the upper minors with a .776 OPS in nearly 1,000 plate appearances at Double A and Triple A. He may not stand out tools-wise, but he's a grinder who can fake it in center field and show some gap power.
SS Lucius Fox (S/R, 6'1 175, 19 in 2017)
2016 statistics with Class-A Augusta: 331 PA, .207/.305/.277 SLG, 12 XBH, 25-for-32 SB, 11.2 BB%, 23.0 K%
Fox was originally signed by San Francisco, but the Rays' acquisition of him gives the organization a top international prospect from consecutive signing periods, along with Adrian Rondon. After a pro debut in full-season ball that proved too ambitious, a bone bruise prevented him from ever suiting up for his new organization. Hopefully that doesn't affect his plus-or-better speed moving forward, which helps him on the bases and will keep him up the middle of the diamond. His approach needs some work, and that would help him make more contact.
RHP Taylor Guerrieri (6'3 195, 24 in 2017)
2016 statistics with Double-A Montgomery: 146 IP, 3.76 ERA, 1.21 WHIP, 7.6 BB%, 14.7 K%
Guerrieri finally had a completely healthy season in 2016, and he threw a career-high 146 innings with the Biscuits. That healthy season, however, apparently came with diminished fastball velocity. His strikeout rate was the lowest of his career, and his walk rate was also the highest. He still works with a solid breaking ball and changeup, and he still gets a lot of balls on the ground. Maybe the fastball will come back in his second season off surgery.
OF Joe McCarthy (L/L, 6'3 225, 23 in 2017)
2016 statistics with Class-A Bowling Green and Class A-Advanced Charlotte: 430 PA, .285/.398/.430, 32 XBH, 8 HR, 19-for-24 SB, 14.2 BB%, 15.8 K%
The Red Scare started the season with a conservative assignment to the Midwest League, but he ended up playing more games in the Florida State League with Charlotte. McCarthy spent most of the early months only playing first base, but he was back in his natural outfield spots later. He adds value in the field and on the bases with decent athleticism. At the plate, he makes good contact and really knows the strike zone. How much power he'll hit for in games remains an open question.
3B Kevin Padlo (R/R, 6'2 205, 20 in 2017)
2016 statistics with Class-A Bowling Green: 509 PA, .229/.358/.413, 16 HR, 41 XBH, 14-for-23 SB, 15.5 BB%, 26.3 K%
Padlo was acquired in the minor league portion of last year's trade that sent Jake McGee to Colorado, and his second attempt at full-season ball was much better than his first, despite a slow start. He already hits for power, particularly to his pull side with many of his home runs going to straightaway left field. He should play above-average defense with a strong arm. Perhaps he could hit for a higher average if he got a little more aggressive early in counts.
C David Rodriguez (R/R, 6'1 215, 21 in 2017)
2016 statistics with Class-A Bowling Green: 472 PA, .240/.321/.349, 26 XBH, 9 HR, 9.3 BB%, 18.6 K%
Rodriguez threw out an absurd 56 percent of attempted basestealers, and he has the potential to develop into a contributor both at and behind the plate. Like many young catchers, he still has to clean up his mechanics defensively, but that should come with more experience. In the batter's box, he owns a patient approach and puts his bat on the ball. He does have a bit of power potential.
RHP Ryne Stanek (6'4 180, 25 in 2017)
2016 statistics with Double-A Montgomery and Triple-A Durham: 102 2/3 IP, 4.30 ERA, 1.31 WHIP, 11.2 BB%, 26.3 K%
After two more underwhelming months in the rotation, Stanek moved to the bullpen and was effective firing triple-digit heat in short stints. Someone whose only exposure to him was the Futures Game probably didn't come away impressed, but his fastball and slider are both swing-and-miss pitches that can make him effective in high-leverage situations. Before he makes the majors, he has to improve his command and control.
CF Garrett Whitley (R/R, 6'1 205, 20 in 2017)
2016 statistics with short-season Hudson Valley: 292 PA, .266/.356/.379, 21-for-26 SB, 20 XBH, 10.3 BB%, 25.7 K%
After a poor pro debut and rough start to 2016, anxiety began to set in among fans in regard to Whitley, but with a July stretch of hits in eight of nine games sparked the raw outfielder to a nice finish. He's patient, but he needs to cut down on his strikeouts to tap into his offensive tools. His impressive bat speed gives him plus power potential, and he has the athleticism and arm to be an above-average center fielder.
OF Justin Williams (L/R, 6'2 215, 21 in 2017)
2016 statistics with Class A-Advanced Charlotte and Double-A Montgomery: 358 PA, .295/.318/.447, 30 XBH, 10 HR, 3.1 BB%, 15.6 K%
It feels like Williams has been around forever already, but he was only 17 when Arizona drafted him in 2013. Long dinged for his aggressive plate approach, he's now in the upper minors, where we'll get a better idea of if he can make it work. He started tapping into his very good power potential a little more with Montgomery, and despite that approach, he regularly makes hard contact and doesn't strike out a lot. He can probably be an average defensive corner outfielder.
RHP Hunter Wood (6'1 175, 23 in 2017)
2016 statistics with Class A-Advanced Charlotte and Double-A Montgomery: 113 IP, 2.39 ERA, 1.01 WHIP, 9.8 BB%, 23.5 K%
Wood was a late addition to the 40-man roster, saving him from a near-certain selection in the Rule 5 draft. A broken thumb briefly interrupted his breakout season, but he still finished with a career high in innings. In those innings, he finished with the lowest WHIP among pitchers in the organization with more than 100 innings. He racks up strikeouts with a fastball that can touch the mid-90s and an above-average curveball. Further development of his changeup will determine his ultimate role.