After a close vote for the No. 3 spot on our list, Jesus Sanchez won in a blowout for No. 4. It wasn’t the most lopsided vote we’ve had, but he did receive more votes in one poll than anyone has yet.
We’ll do Tuesday and Friday votes next week as well.
2018 Community prospect list
|1||RHP Brent Honeywell||24||33||72.7%||2|
|2||SS Willy Adames||23||24||95.8%||1|
|3||1B/LHP Brendan McKay||16||34||47.1%||N/A|
|4||OF Jesus Sanchez||26||35||74.3%||9|
|5||1B/OF Jake Bauers||29||39||74.4%||4|
|6||OF Justin Williams||24||35||68.6%||17|
|7||IF Christian Arroyo||19||38||50.0%||N/A|
|8||OF Garrett Whitley||15||36||41.7%||15|
|9||LHP Anthony Banda||Special||election||N/A|
|10||RHP Jose De Leon||15||33||45.5%||3|
|11||OF Joshua Lowe||13||30||43.3%||7|
|12||SS Lucius Fox||16||36||44.4%||13|
|13||SS Wander Franco||13||35||37.1%||N/A|
|14||RHP Austin Franklin||17||33||51.5%||22|
|15||RHP Tobias Myers||11||32||34.4%||N/A|
|16||2B Nick Solak||Special||election||N/A|
|17||RHP Michael Mercado||7||27||25.9%||N/A|
|18||1B/OF Joe McCarthy||9||33||27.3%||25|
|19||2B Brandon Lowe||7||31||22.6%||N/R|
|20||RHP Chih-Wei Hu||8||28||28.6%||6|
|21||RHP Jaime Schultz||9||32||28.1%||12|
|22||C Ronaldo Hernandez||11||30||36.7%||N/R|
|23||RHP Diego Castillo||9||25||36.0%||50|
|24||RHP Yonny Chirinos||12||28||42.9%||41|
|25||2B Vidal Brujan||10||28||35.7%||N/R|
|26||RHP Ryne Stanek||8||25||32.0%||20|
|27||LHP Resly Linares||7||26||26.9%||47|
|28||LHP Genesis Cabrera||12||27||44.4%||23|
|29||3B Kevin Padlo||9||27||33.3%||14|
|30||LHP Ryan Yarbrough||13||29||44.8%||19|
|31||LHP Brock Burke||N/R|
|32||RHP Drew Strotman||N/A|
|33||SS Jermaine Palacios||N/A|
|34||C Brett Sullivan||26|
|35||C Nick Ciuffo||24|
|36||OF Ryan Boldt||38|
|37||IF Carlos Vargas||27|
|38||3B Adrian Rondon||11|
|39||LHP Travis Ott||40|
|40||RHP Curtis Taylor||N/A|
IF Christian Arroyo (R/R, 6’1 180, 23 in 2018)
2017 statistics with San Francisco: 135 PA, .192/.244/.304, 8 XBH, 5.9 BB%, 30.5 K%
2017 statistics with Triple-A Sacramento: 102 PA, .396/.461/.604, 4 HR, 11 XBH, 5.9 BB%, 11.8 K%
The biggest problem for Arroyo in 2017 was likely not his struggles in his brief big league debut, but the hand injury that required surgery in November to address. He was hit in that hand twice during the season. Defensively, he should be able to handle second or third base, and he’ll need his hit tool to carry him. He’s not too selective, but he is a career .300 hitter in the minors. He has never hit more than nine home runs or stole more than seven bases in a season.
1B/OF Jake Bauers (L/L, 6’1 195, 22 in 2018)
2017 statistics with Triple-A Durham: 575 PA, .263/.368/.412, 31 2B, 13 HR, 20-of-23 SB, 13.6 BB%, 19.5 K%
Like Willy Adames, Bauers’ 2017 season with Durham was very similar to his 2016 with Montgomery, although it is perhaps notable that his strikeout rate was a new career high. Despite that, his hit tool is still his best, and that’s what will get him to the majors. He’s able to wait for his pitch and make good contact. His 45 extra-base hits tied a career high, and he could have average power. After two seasons of experimentation in the outfield, he seems more and more like a regular first baseman.
SS Lucius Fox (S/R, 6’1 175, 20 in 2018)
2017 statistics with Class-A Bowling Green and Class A-Advanced Charlotte: 476 PA, .266/.350/.341, 30-of-43 SB, 22 XBH, 9.5 BB%, 23.7 K%
After a rough pro debut with the Giants in 2016, Fox rebounded in his Rays organization debut, even earning a spot in the Futures Game. He batted .278 with a .361 on-base percentage with Bowling Green before a promotion to Charlotte, where he struggled as a 19 year old. He doesn’t have much power potential, so he’ll have to refine his approach and make more contact to better use his plus-plus speed, as he did with the Hot Rods. He has the physical tools necessary to stay at shortstop.
RHP Jaime Schultz (5’10 200, 27 in 2018)
2017 statistics with Triple-A Durham: 11 2⁄3 IP, 3.86 ERA, 1.20 WHIP, 8.0 BB%, 42.0 K%
Schultz almost certainly would’ve made his big league debut in 2017 had a persistent groin injury not sidelined him for much of the season. It was not the first groin injury of his career. In his limited work with Durham, he pitched out of the bullpen for the first time, and he was electric, striking out more than two batters out of every five he faced. If he throws strikes with his mid-90s fastball and plus breaking ball, he can be a dominant reliever.
OF Garrett Whitley (R/R, 6’1 195, 21 in 2018)
2017 statistics with Class-A Bowling Green: 426 PA, .249.,362/.430, 13 HR, 35 XBH, 21-of-25 SB, 13.4 BB%, 28.6 K%
After his customary slow start to the season, Whitley showed off all of his tools with Bowling Green. The 2015 13th-overall pick is a great athlete with impressive power potential, hitting 10 of his 13 home runs over the season’s final two months. Although his walk rate is encouraging, his astronomical strikeout rate is going to have to come down at some point. While he spent most of 2017 in a corner outfield spot, he should have no problem playing center field.
OF Justin Williams (L/R, 6’2 215, 22 in 2018)
2017 statistics with Double-A Montgomery: 409 PA, .301/.364/.489, 14 HR, 38 XBH, 9.0 BB%, 16.9 K%
If Williams developers into a quality big leaguer, his month of August in 2017 will be looked back on as the turning point of his career. He batted .333 with a .411 on-base percentage, eight home runs and 16 extra-base hits and even walked more than he struck out. He always had the swing and power potential to profile in a corner outfield spot — it’s a matter of being patient and waiting for his pitches. His walk 9.0 percent walk rate was by far the best in his career so far.